“Think for yourselves and let others enjoy the privilege to do so, too.”
Censorship, defined by Laws.com, is the act of altering, adjusting, editing or banning of any or all media resulting from the presumption that its content is perceived to be objectionable, incendiary, illicit or immoral, including:
• Periodicals (published with set frequency)
• Television programs
• Radio programs
• Internet (websites and email)
• News reports
Censorship can reliably be traced back to 399 BC when Socrates was sentenced to drink poison. He was dually charged with “refusing to recognize the gods recognized by the state” and of “corrupting the youth.”
In modern times, censorship involving violence (any media promotion or undertaking with the intent to cause harm) and activities of a sexual nature (pornographic images, especially of those below the age of eighteen, or acts involving animals, violence, injury and simulated relationships illicit and unlawful in nature) has become more and more a necessity. And laws such as the Rape Shield Law help prevent a victim’s identity from being revealed, as well as past sexual behavior being used to undermine the victim’s credibility.
Aside from such direct violation of legislation, there is no set measure for censorship. Anything outside specific legislation generally must undergo judicial review, whether the complainant be the government, church, private pressure group or an individual.
Meanwhile, the debate rages on. From book banning to regulating the internet, censorship has always had its protagonists and antagonists. While some believe it is necessary to maintain a moral and healthy society, others believe it has shadowed free expression throughout history.
According to GreenGarage there are nine primary pros and cons of censorship.
• Censorship regulation, especially on the internet, can keep people, particularly children, from exposure to pornographic materials and racial discrimination. Restricting access, in print or online, can protect them from being victims of sexual abuse and racism or themselves becoming perpetrators.
• Censorship limits access to sensitive and confidential information that can put the security of nations out in the open.
• Censorship limits the exposure of people, particularly children, to violent and vulgar television, especially shows whose storylines border on glorifying criminals and mass murderers.
• Parents are not always there to monitor the shows their children are watching and the websites they are visiting. By censoring channels/sites children can gain access to, parents are assured information is age appropriate.
• Screening and monitoring of irresponsible and/or the bold use of expletives, scenes and tactics reduces offense to varying members of society, no matter their walk of life.
• Censorship of media can be used by powerful people, such as politicians or leaders, to hide information that can harm their reputation or reveal illegal activities.
• Propaganda and censorship go hand in hand and can be used by government to wreak havoc and fear, especially during times of civil unrest.
• Especially in regards to the Internet, loopholes, lack of enforcement, number of sites created (daily) and hacking make censorship ineffective. A large portion of the national budget is needed, for equipment, law enforcement and prosecution, just to try to keep up.
• As it regards to countries that use censorship of the Internet, progress and development advancement can be affected as people are denied its readily available knowledge and breaking information, which can help enrich the lives of its citizens.
Throughout history, one of the most prolific uses of censorship has been book banning. On March 12, 2012, it was reported that a South Carolina teacher was placed on administrative leave after reading excerpts from three books (including Ender’s Game) after one mother complained to the school and police about “pornographic” reading materials. There is speculation the teacher also was reading from the Internet, but the school maintains the teacher was only reading from the books. While the teacher initially faced criminal charges, the investigation has been closed. Whether the teacher was cleared by the school for “breach of school policy” is undetermined. All media in that regard has disappeared except for the search results themselves.
Common Sense Media (commonsensemedia.org), an organization that rates, educates and advocates for kids, families and schools, says Ender’s Game should not be read by children under twelve. The average age of the students in the South Carolina class was fourteen.
Many books throughout the years have faced banning and challenges. The popular Harry Potter series has long been under fire for the advocacy and promotion of witchcraft, satanic material and the occult. And when the Library of Congress* created its exhibit “Books that Shaped America,” thirty out of the eighty-eight books were, at one point or another, banned or challenged.
Certainly there is need for very specific types of censorship – to protect the young from being victimized or keep warfare technologies out of the hands of terrorists. But a responsible, thoughtful person or society should be able to make its own informed decisions.
After all, if someone doesn’t like what is being said on a radio station program, they may exercise their right to change the station just as someone who enjoys it should be allowed to listen. Perhaps Henry Steele Commager said it best, “The fact is that censorship always defeats its own purpose, for it creates, in the end, the kind of society that is incapable of exercising real discretion.”
LIBRARY OF CONGRESS “BOOKS THAT SHAPED AMERICA”
Books from the list that have been “banned” or “challenged”
The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn Mark Twain 1884
Concord, MA in 1885 called it “trash and suitable only for the slums.” Objections to the book have evolved, but only marginally. Twain’s book is one of the most-challenged of all time and is frequently challenged even today because of its frequent use of the word “nigger.” Otherwise it is alleged the book is “racially insensitive,” “oppressive,” and “perpetuates racism.”
The Autobiography of Malcolm X Malcolm X and Alex Haley 1965
Objectors have called this seminal work a “how-to-manual” for crime and decried because of “anti-white statements” present in the book. The book presents the life story of Malcolm Little, also known as Malcolm X, who was a human rights activist and who has been called one of the most influential Americans in recent history.
Beloved Toni Morrison 1987
Again and again, this Pulitzer-prize winning novel by perhaps the most influential African-American writer of all time is assigned to high school English students. And again and again, parental complaints are lodged against the book because of its violence, sexual content and discussion of bestiality.
Bury My Heart at Wounded Knee Dee Brown 1970
Subtitled “An Indian History of the American West,” this book tells the history of United States growth and expansion into the West from the point of view of Native Americans. This book was banned by a school district official in Wisconsin in 1974 because the book might be polemical and they wanted to avoid controversy at all costs. “If there’s a possibility that something might be controversial, then why not eliminate it,” the official stated.
The Call of the Wild Jack London 1903
Generally hailed as Jack London’s best work, The Call of the Wild is commonly challenged for its dark tone and bloody violence. Because it is seen as a man-and-his-dog story, it is sometimes read by adolescents and subsequently challenged for age-inappropriateness. Not only have objections been raised here, the book was banned in Italy, Yugoslavia and burned in bonfires in Nazi Germany in the late 1920s and early 30s because it was considered “too radical.”
Catch-22 Joseph Heller 1961
A school board in Strongsville, OH refused to allow the book to be taught in high school English classrooms in 1972. It also refused to consider Cat’s Cradle as a substitute text and removed both books from the school library. The issue eventually led to a 1976 District Court ruling overturning the ban in Minarcini v. Strongsville.
The Catcher in the Rye J.D. Salinger 1951
Young Holden, favorite child of the censor. Frequently removed from classrooms and school libraries because it is “unacceptable,” “obscene,” “blasphemous,” “negative,” “foul,” “filthy,” and “undermines morality.” And to think Holden always thought “people never notice anything.”
Fahrenheit 451 Ray Bradbury 1953
Rather than ban the book about book-banning outright, Venado Middle school in Irvine, CA utilized an expurgated version of the text in which all the “hells” and “damns” were blacked out. Other complaints have said the book went against objectors religious beliefs. The book’s author, Ray Bradbury, died this year.
For Whom the Bell Tolls Ernest Hemingway 1940
Shortly after its publication the U.S. Post Office, which purpose was in part to monitor and censor distribution of media and texts, declared the book nonmailable. In the 1970s, eight Turkish booksellers were tried for “spreading propaganda unfavorable to the state” because they had published and distributed the text. This wasn’t Hemingway’s only banned book – A Farewell to Arms and Across the River and Into the Trees were also censored domestically and abroad in Ireland, South Africa, Germany and Italy.
Gone With the Wind Margaret Mitchell 1936
The Pulitzer-prize winning novel (which three years after its publication became an Academy-Award Winning film) follows the life of the spoiled daughter of a southern plantation owner just before and then after the fall of the Confederacy and decline of the South in the aftermath of the Civil War. Critically praised for its thought-provoking and realistic depiction of ante- and postbellum life in the South, it has also been banned for more or less the same reasons. Its realism has come under fire, specifically its realistic portrayal – though at times perhaps tending toward optimistic — of slavery and use of the words “nigger” and “darkies.”
The Grapes of Wrath John Steinbeck 1939
Kern County, California has the great honor both of being the setting of Steinbeck’s novel and being the first place where it was banned (1939). Objections to profanity—especially goddamn and the like—and sexual references continued from then into the 1990s. It is a work with international banning appeal: the book was barred in Ireland in the 50s and a group of booksellers in Turkey were taken to court for “spreading propaganda” in 1973.
The Great Gatsby F. Scott Fitzgerald 1925
Perhaps the first great American novel that comes to the mind of the average person, this book chronicles the booze-infused and decadent lives of East Hampton socialites. It was challenged at the Baptist College in South Carolina because of the book’s language and mere references to sex.
Howl Allen Ginsberg 1956
Following in the footsteps of other “Shaping America” book Leaves of Grass by Walt Whitman, Allen Ginsberg’s boundary-pushing poetic works were challenged because of descriptions of homosexual acts.
In Cold Blood Truman Capote 1966
The subject of controversy in an AP English class in Savannah, GA after a parent complained about sex, violence and profanity. Banned but brought back.
Invisible Man Ralph Ellison 1952
Ellison’s book won the 1953 National Book Award for Fiction because it expertly dealt with issues of black nationalism, Marxism and identity in the twentieth century. Considered to be too expert in its ruminations for some high schools, the book was banned from high school reading lists and schools in Pennsylvania, Wisconsin and Washington state.
The Jungle Upton Sinclair 1906
For decades, American students have studied muckraking and yellow journalism in social studies lessons about the industrial revolution, with The Jungle headlining the unit. And yet, the dangerous and purportedly socialist views expressed in the book and Sinclair’s Oil led to its being banned in Yugoslavia, East Germany, South Korea and Boston.
Leaves of Grass Walt Whitman 1855
If they don’t understand you, sometimes they ban you. This was the case when the great American poem was first published and the New York Society for the Suppression of Vice found the sensuality of the text disturbing. Caving to pressure, booksellers in New York, Massachusetts and Pennsylvania conceded to advising their patrons not to buy the “filthy” book.
Moby-Dick; or The Whale Herman Melville 1851
In a real head-scratcher of a case, a Texas school district banned the book from its Advanced English class lists because it “conflicted with their community values” in 1996. Community values are frequently cited in discussions over challenged books by those who wish to censor them.
Native Son Richard Wright 1940
Richard Wright’s landmark work of literary naturalism follows the life of young Bigger Thomas, a poor Black man living on the South Side of Chicago. Bigger is faced with numerous awkward and frustrating situations when he begins working for a rich white family as their chauffer. After he unintentionally kills a member of the family, he flees but is eventually caught, tried and sentenced to death. The book has been challenged or removed in at least eight different states because of objections to “violent and sexually graphic” content.
Our Bodies, Ourselves Boston Women’s Health Book Collective 1971
Challenges of this book about the female anatomy and sexuality ran from the book’s publication into the mid-1980s. One Public Library lodged it “promotes homosexuality and perversion.” Not surprising in a country where some legislators want to keep others from saying the word “vagina.”
The Red Badge of Courage Stephen Crane 1895
Restricting access and refusing to allow teachers to teach books is still a form of censorship in many cases. Crane’s book was among many on a list compiled by the Bay District School board in 1986 after parents began lodging informal complaints about books in an English classroom library.
The Scarlet Letter Nathaniel Hawthorne 1850
According to many critics, Hawthorne should have been less friendly toward his main character, Hester Prynne (in fairness, so should have minister Arthur Dimmesdale). One isn’t surprised by the moralist outrage the book caused in 1852. But when, one hundred and forty years later, the book is still being banned because it is sinful and conflicts with community values, you have to raise your eyebrows. Parents in one school district called the book “pornographic and obscene” in 1977. Clearly this was before the days of the World Wide Web.
Sexual Behavior in the Human Male Alfred C. Kinsey 1948
How dare Alfred Kinsey ask men and women questions about their sex lives! The groundbreaking study, truly the first of its scope and kind, was banned from publication abroad and highly criticized at home.
Stranger in a Strange Land Robert A. Heinlein 1961
The book was actually retained after a 2003 challenge in Mercedes, TX to the book’s adult themes. However, parents were subsequently given more control over what their child was assigned to read in class, a common school board response to a challenge.
A Streetcar Named Desire Tennessee Williams 1947
The sexual content of this play, which later became a popular and critically acclaimed film, raised eyebrows and led to self-censorship when the film was being made. The director left a number of scenes on the cutting room floor to get an adequate rating and protect against complaints of the play’s immorality.
Their Eyes Were Watching God Zora Neale Hurston 1937
Parents of students in Advanced English classes in a Virginia high school objected to language and sexual content in this book, which made TIME magazine’s list of top 100 Best English-Language Novels from 1923 to 2005.
To Kill a Mockingbird Harper Lee 1960
Harper Lee’s great American tome stands as proof positive that the censorious impulse is alive and well in our country, even today. For some educators, the Pulitzer-prize winning book is one of the greatest texts teens can study in an American literature class. Others have called it a degrading, profane and racist work that “promotes white supremacy.”
Uncle Tom’s Cabin Harriet Beecher Stowe 1852
Like Huck Finn, Of Mice and Men and Gone With the Wind, the contextual, historically and culturally accurate depiction of the treatment of Black slaves in the United States has rankled would-be censors.
Where the Wild Things Are Maurice Sendak 1963
Sendak’s work is beloved by children in the generations since its publication and has captured the collective imagination. Many parents and librarians, however, did much hand-wringing over the dark and disturbing nature of the story. They also wrung their hands over the baby’s penis drawn in In the Night Kitchen.
The Words of Cesar Chavez Cesar Chavez 2002
The works of Chavez were among the many books banned in the dissolution of the Mexican-American Studies Program in Tucson, Arizona. The Tucson Unified School District disbanded the program so as to accord with a piece of legislation which outlawed Ethnic Studies classes in the state.
List and descriptions supplied by Banned Books Week.
Sources: bannedbooksweek.org/censorship/bannedbooksthatshapedamerica, censorship.laws.com/censorship-in-america, greengarageblog.org/9-primary-pros-and-cons-of-censorship, censorship.laws.com/banned-books, media.okstate.edu/faculty/jsenat/censorship/defining.htm, beaconforfreedom.org/liste.html?tid=415&art_id=475, eyewitnesstohistory.com/socrates.htm, adweek.com/galleycat/police-drop-criminal-investigation-against-middle-school-teacher-who-read-enders-game-in-class/4988, forbes.com/sites/erikkain/2012/03/19/south-carolina-teacher-suspended-for-reading-enders-game-to-middle-school-students/, loc.gov/bookfest/books-that-shaped-america/.